
Exploring Camp Nou renovation
I’m looking at the major renovation of the Spotify Camp Nou being done by Nikken Sekkei and b720 Fermín Vázquez, which is set from 2022-2025. There's some discussion about how this renovation could distort the stadium's architectural essence, especially with the addition of corporate boxes and a media façade. The original design focused on minimalist modernism with an open bowl and asymmetric stands. I could provide a brief summary of this context and ask if there’s interest in a translation or deeper analysis.Discussing Camp Nou renovation concerns
Critics say the renovation is turning the Camp Nou into a shopping mall and losing the concrete’s tectonic expression in favor of a shiny commercial wrapper. I see the user's request is open-ended, so I should ask for clarification. Would they like a translation, context, or an architectural critique? My short summary could discuss the original design’s emphasis on structural honesty and the new plan’s inclusion of a covered roof and commercial spaces, raising questions about authenticity. Should I provide a quick comparison or an in-depth analysis?
这是在批评“新诺坎普”(Spotify Camp Nou 的重建方案)背离了原体育场的建筑精神:从结构与空间的“诚实、开放”,转向被媒体立面、商业包厢与整体包裹的屋顶主导的体验。
快速背景
- 原诺坎普:1950s 现代主义/理性主义取向,混凝土结构清晰外露、开放看台与城市相连,尺度朴素,重“结构的表达”和群众性。
- 新方案(Nikken Sekkei + b720):增至 ~10.5 万席,环形屋顶覆盖,全周媒体立面与大型商业层,包厢/贵宾区显著增加,动线与无障碍升级,强调赛事日与非赛事日的商业复合功能与可持续。
为何被指“歪曲本质”
- 结构诚实性被包裹:原有清晰的看台与结构节奏被连续立面与屋盖统一包装,材料与受力关系更难被直观感知。
- 场所精神弱化:开放、与城市“呼吸”的球场变为更封闭的“容器”,象征性与日常可达性体验改变。
- 商业优先于公共性:包厢与赞助商界面(LED/媒体立面)强化,观演民主性与“人民的球场”气质被稀释。
- 尺度与感官:新增层级与包裹面可能改变看台坡度、视线与噪声/回响,影响原有粗粝而直接的现场感。
支持方常见回应

- 功能与安全:通行、无障碍、疏散、座椅舒适度等大幅提升。
- 经济与可持续:能源、雨水利用、遮阳降噪与赛事外运营能力增强,有助俱乐部长期财政。
- 传承与更新:保留场址与容量、延续外形意象,同时满足21世纪赛事与城市复合业态需求。
你希望我做哪种帮助?
- 翻译这句话或相关文章要点成英文
- 做一页式“原 vs 新”设计对比清单(功能/形象/体验/经济)
- 从建筑学角度写一段短评或辩论稿
- 整理时间线与参与团队简介(无八卦版本)

.gif)